
The Women’s Game is an exclusive editorial series written by writer, broadcaster, and former college and pro soccer player Renee Washington for BrooklynFootballClub.com. Each week, Renee goes behind the scenes with Brooklyn FC Women, giving unique insights into the squad and sharing stories of the people behind the crest.
As a 16-year-old growing up in Yarmouth, Maine, a small coastal town just outside Portland that traces its roots to the 1700s and the Massachusetts Bay Colony, Brooklyn FC Women’s midfielder Sara D’Appolonia had one goal: to play Division I college soccer.
She was adamant and determined. But at that time, long before Portland Hearts of Pine and the recently founded women’s team Maine Wildness, the coast of Maine was not a soccer hotbed. Getting the type of high-quality competition she needed, let alone being recruited by college programs, was no easy feat.
So she went to extraordinary lengths to make it happen.

“During my sophomore year of high school, I played for New England FC in Massachusetts, which meant driving more than two hours each way, alone, several times a week at 16,” she recalls. “I’d leave straight after school, do my homework at a Panera or Dunkin once I got there, go to training, and get home close to midnight. Then wake up for school the next morning, as usual.”
Beyond the obvious fatigue, the effort took its toll on the multi-sport athlete in very personal ways. D’Appolonia’s soccer exploits for Yarmouth High School were the stuff of legend — four-year starter, two state championships, Maine Gatorade Player of the Year in 2017 — but she lost a season of basketball. The basketball team was coached by her mother, Christina Strong, a former standout for the University of Maine who was recently inducted into the Maine Sports Hall of Fame.
“That decision strained our relationship,” she admits. “And I missed out on much of the conventional high school experience.”
And despite the family friction it caused at the time, D’Appolonia looks back now and realizes that her decision to follow her heart so vehemently was rooted in her DNA. Her father was a college soccer goalkeeper and her mother, in addition to her basketball prowess, was a high school soccer player who competed on the boys’ team because there wasn’t a girls’ team at the time.
“My dad was the one who encouraged me to take these leaps of faith and chase my dreams,” she says. “And my mom — though she may not realize it — is the one who showed me fierce independence and gave me the strength to make hard decisions.”
Taking It to the Next Level
Ultimately, the sacrifices paid off, just as she had anticipated.
“It put me in front of college coaches at tournaments and showcases I never would have reached otherwise,” she says. “It gave me the exposure and contacts to play Division I soccer.”

One of the programs that liked what they saw in D’Appolonia was the University of Delaware. She was so excited for the opportunity to join the Bluehens that she graduated high school a semester early to move to Delaware, train with the college team, and begin studying biology and public health.
“It meant leaving my friends and the final stretch of senior year behind, but it gave me a jump on both my athletic and academic goals,” she says.
D’Appolonia would go on to enjoy a stellar collegiate career, making 77 appearances and scoring 17 goals for the Bluehens. She earned multiple league recognition, including being named to the 2019 All-CAA First Team and CAA All-Tournament team.
Farther Afield
In the middle of D’Appolonia’s junior season, COVID-19 hit. College soccer, just like the rest of the world, came to an abrupt halt.
Never one to be stopped from pursuing her goal, D’Appolonia found an opportunity despite the global shutdown. An international recruiter recruited her to play as an amateur for FC Malaga City on the coast of Spain.
“It seemed outrageous to move abroad during a pandemic,” she says today, “but my gut told me to leave Delaware that fall, when there was no competitive season, and go on an adventure. My college coach, Mike Barroquiero, supported the decision and helped make it happen.”
In Spain, like in Maine, she was forced to make sacrifices and daily adjustments to keep up with her ambitions, like taking her physics exams at one in the morning because of the time change.
But, again, it was worth it.
“I didn’t mind,” she says,” because I was living a once-in-a-lifetime experience. My teammates and I shared a villa with a balcony overlooking our training ground and the Mediterranean Sea. I couldn’t believe it was my life.”

Eventually, she returned to Delaware to finish out her playing career as college soccer emerged from the pandemic. But she had clearly made an impression in Spain.
“While there, I was recruited to play professionally and offered a contract with a Spanish club,” she says. “That moment made me believe I was capable of more and could chase my dream of going pro. I ultimately turned the offer down, finished my degree at Delaware, and then chose to begin my professional career in Australia.”
In October 2023, D’Appolonia signed with Women’s A-League powerhouse Melbourne Victory. The woman who, as a girl, used to drive two hours to play elite youth soccer was now with a top-flight club on the literal other side of the world. She made an immediate impact, debuting the month she arrived and going on to make 47 appearances, with one goal, across two seasons.
“Taking that leap of faith during a time of such uncertainty gave me one of my fondest memories in soccer,” she says.
Soccer Player or a Person Who Plays Soccer?
D’Appolonia is listed as a midfielder, but she has the versatility to play any position other than goalkeeper.
“My college coach once asked me, ‘Are you a soccer player, or are you a person that plays soccer?’” she says. “My answer has become something I now live by. I’m not a soccer player; I’m a person who plays soccer, and my versatility reflects that.

“I’ve turned what could be a weakness into my greatest asset by staying coachable and willing to play anywhere. I’m constantly adapting while trying to master my craft wherever I’m placed. It can be frustrating, but I look for the bright side and make the most of every opportunity.”
To some, such adaptability is an obvious advantage. But it has the unfortunate possibility of introducing a complication in today’s highly specialized pro soccer culture.
“When a manager or agent asks what position I prefer or what my position is, I’m almost lost for words,” she says. “But this struggle reminds me that my identity has never been a position or even my sport for I am not a soccer player but a person that plays soccer. It’s who I am as a person: adaptable, resilient, and committed to doing what the team needs.”
She adds: “Soccer is what I do, not all of who I am.”
Behind the Number 13
After a short stint in the German 2nd division, D’Appolonia signed with Brooklyn FC ahead of the 2027 Gainbridge Super League Fall Season. She made her first appearance for the club against Fort Lauderdale United FC in August and has since racked up a total of 10 appearances, including 8 starts.
Upon joining BKFC, she chose the #13 jersey.
“The number 13 holds a lot of significance in my family,” she explains. “For starters, my father and mother met at the University of Maine where he wore #1 as a goalkeeper on the Men’s soccer team and she wore #3 as a point guard on the Women’s basketball team.”
The number also appears, weirdly, in the names of each of the three children in the D’Appolonia family.
“They unintentionally named all three of us with 13 letters in our first and middle names combined (Sara Elizabeth, John Sebastian & Katelyn Olivia),” she says. “So needless to say, the number is an important symbol in our family. While many consider it unlucky, I consider it just the opposite: lucky!”
It’s so powerful and important, D’Appolonia has the number tattooed on her arm.
Giving Back to the Game
As her playing career has grown and she has continued to live her mantra of being a person who plays soccer, D’Appolonia has found ways to make an impact off the pitch.
She began coaching in Delaware, continued in Australia, and today still works with young players when she returns to Maine. It’s a passion inspired by her own experiences growing up in Yarmouth and seeking high-level soccer.
“I didn’t have a local soccer idol growing up,” she says, “so being that for girls back home, or wherever my playing career takes me, is special and important to me.”

DID YOU KNOW?
Beyond the game, D’Appolonia enjoys reading, watercolor painting, dog walking, exploring restaurants and spending time outdoors. She dedicates some of her time to having an impact on kids in Maine by supporting Time to Compete, a nonprofit organization that helps support young adults battling cancer, which honors her late high school friend Gibson Harnett.
UP NEXT
The Brooklyn FC Women continue their chase for the playoffs on Saturday, November 21, on the road at Tampa Bay Sun FC. The match kicks off at 6:00 PM and streams live on Peacock.
The next home match is the regular season finale on Saturday, November 28, when BKFC host Lexington SC on Fan Appreciation Night. The match kicks off at 6:00 PM.


















































































































































































































































































